top of page
Search

Hours from Help: Why a Three-Hour Rescue Calls for More Than a Standard Suit

diego7475
Nov 6
4 min read

Close to shore is not close to help


Many crews work within sight of land, or within a few hours of it: tugs and barges, fishing vessels, offshore supply and crew boats, ferries, coastal cargo ships, and research and government vessels. It is natural to assume that rescue would come quickly. In cold water, that assumption deserves a second look. Even a three-hour wait is long enough for a standard immersion suit to fail the person wearing it.

The reason is not the length of the wait alone. It is what happens inside a suit when water gets in, and in a real abandonment, water almost always gets in.



Why three hours is a realistic planning case


Rescue times depend on far more than distance from shore. For any vessel in cold water, several conditions can stretch a short distance into a long wait:


  • The weather that causes the casualty also slows the rescue. Heavy seas, high winds and icing can ground helicopters and keep small boats in port.

  • Darkness and poor visibility make people in the water much harder to find.

  • Remote routes and fishing grounds take vessels along empty coastlines and offshore, often as the only vessel in the area.

  • Search and rescue assets are shared. A cutter or helicopter may be committed elsewhere, or several hours away, when the call comes.

  • A capsize can be sudden. Girting on a tow, icing or a shifting load on a fishing vessel, or sudden flooding may leave no time to send a distress call or launch a liferaft.


None of these is unusual. Together, they make a wait of three hours or more a reasonable case for any operator to plan for in cold water.


The hidden variable: water inside the suit


Standard immersion suits are certified to IMO MSC.81(70). The thermal test is carried out under controlled conditions, with the amount of water allowed to enter the suit limited to 500 grams. Standard LSA suits were never designed nor tested for the conditions of a real cold-water abandonment.


In practice, water gets inside. Crew may jump from height, don the suit in a hurry on a heeling deck, enter the water before the zipper is fully closed, or put the suit on after they are already wet. Waves force water past seals and the face opening. The wearer's clothing, which provides much of the insulation in a conventional suit, then becomes soaked.


Once that happens, a standard suit loses a large part of its protection. Arvid Johan Påsche of Ergopro, the independent cold-water test laboratory in Trondheim, Norway, estimates that about one litre of water inside a conventional immersion suit reduces its thermal protection by 40–45%.


The practical consequence is simple. A suit that is wet inside cannot be relied upon to keep its wearer protected for more than a few hours. If the realistic wait for rescue is three hours or more, a standard suit offers no reliable margin.


This is why a three-hour rescue time is a duty-of-care question, not only a regulatory one.



A suit built to keep working when wet


The Arctic 10+ was designed around this problem. Its insulation is a lining of reflective air bubbles, not foam or the wearer's own clothing, so it keeps its insulating value when water is present. The suit can be donned after the wearer is already wet without losing its protection.


The same reflective bubble insulation is used in the larger Arctic 25+. In Ergopro testing, Arctic 25+ suits were worn with 2.0–2.3 kg of water in the underclothing, several times the 500 g allowed in the standard test. Core temperature changed by −0.8°C and +0.1°C over 180 minutes in the two suits tested. These are Arctic 25+ results, shown here as an indication of how the insulation technology performs when wet.


The Arctic 10+ also offers:

  • 4.87 Clo of thermal insulation (Ergopro static manikin test)

  • 97 lb of buoyancy in certification testing, worn without a lifejacket

  • Current USCG, Transport Canada, EU/UK MED and Chilean DIRECTEMAR approvals

  • A three-year service interval and an expected service life of more than ten years

For an operator, the question is not whether a suit passed its certification test. It is whether it will still protect the crew when it is wet inside and help is hours away.


What operators can do now


Any operator in cold water can test its own exposure with four questions:

  1. On each route, what is the realistic time to rescue in the worst weather you operate in, not the best?

  2. If that time is three hours or more, would your current suits still protect a crew member who is wet inside?

  3. Have your crews practised donning in realistic conditions, including after entering the water?

  4. If a crew member were lost, could you show that your survival equipment matched the conditions you sent them into?


If any answer is uncertain, the gap is worth closing before the next winter season.

White Glacier welcomes conversations with vessel operators, fleet safety managers and designated persons ashore who want to assess their crews' exposure. To arrange a technical briefing or an on-board demonstration, contact Diego Jacobson at djacobson@whiteglacier.com.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page